loutfi a écrit:

Euh non Seth sa GROSSE compète c'est Toronto ! Et il me tarde d'aller le voir de ... PRES !!

De très près ?

Loooooooooove , exciiiiiting and neeeeeeeeeeeeew

...

ICI aussi

la liste des participants en -212:

Sami Ebrahim Ali Alhaddad
Raul Carrasco
Gaetano Cisternino
Nathan Detracy
Mboya Edwards
Kevin English
Milton Holloway
Panexce Pierre
Jose Raymond
Marco Rivera
Luis Santana
Luis Santiago
Naor Ziv

la liste des participants en open:

Sean Allan
Tomas Bures
Jon Delarosa
Vaughn Ettienne
Wendell Floyd
Johnie Jackson
Steve Kuclo
Jeff Long
Cedric McMillan
Juan Morel
Mohammed Touri


C'est drôle Touri était mis dans liste des -212 à la base, ne serait t-il pas au poids ?

http://forums.musculardevelopment.com/showthread.php/126043-IFBB-New-York-Pro-2012-Play-By-Play-with-Peter-McGough-Ron-Harris-amp-Vanessa-11-am-Eastern/page3

c'est parti en -212 :

V.Campell : Sami - super separated - could be a tad sharper - great calves

R.Harris : Sami Al Haddad from Bahrain - wow! thick, awesome shape and ripped


VC : Raul Carraso - The color is off, No thickness in the chest.

VC : Gaetano Cisternino - Good Overall development but a bit long waisted, nice legs and great hams from the side.
Needs to be sharper.
Good thigh separation.

VC : Nathan Detracy - Really good potential, has a great shape. No one has come up yet with nice conditioning.

RH : Raul Carrasco from Spain - very good - not massive - nice proportiona

Guy Cisternino awesome legs still needs to fill out a bit more

Nathan DeTracy in pro debut - thick was sharper at Nats win, but bigger now

VC : Mboya Edwards - Has a Keving English look about him without the WOW factor. His legs don't match his upper body.

VC : Kevin English - Has the arms of a heavy weight. He's not hard and dry.
Looks soft from the back by his own standards.

VC : Milton holloway Jr -Tremedous biceps peek- has been around a long time.His upper body over shadows his lower body

RH : Kevin English - enormous - doesn't have that sharp grainy look - not dry - needs to control gut in some shots - bit soft in glutes and hams

RH: Milton Holloway Jr. - nice shape, great arms and chest - overall not big enough for this group - needs more legs

RH :Panax Pierre - last year's Team U champ - needs to be way bigger and harder for a show like this. Legs in particular need to be MUCH thicker - looks long and lean

VC : Panexce Pierre - Pretty well conditioned but narrow.Doesn't seem like his 212. Looks like a 202.His best body part by far are his pecks.

RH : JOSE RAYMOND - The Boston MASS! Jose brought it - hard as nails - thick as shit - looking to make it two wins in NYC in a row - way harder than Kevin - just gnarly

VC : Jose Raymond - Harder than Kevin English.Separated and vascular. May be a little thick around the waist. Could have been a little tighter there.Giving Kevin a run for his money.

VC : Marco Rivera - Right thigh much bigger than left. Nice and full upper body.Seems to be holding a bit of water in the back.

RH: Marco Rivera from the Bronx - big and full - nice shape - quads a bit watery - legs harder from the back, ironically - overall in very decent condition - lot of love from this crowd

RH : Luis Santa - nice shape and structure, but needs WAY more mass to hang here with the freaks - also could be harder

VC : Luis Santa - Not enough muscle mass to be competitive in this line up. Needs a lot more muscle on.

VC : Luis Santiago - Too soft. Pretty good upper body shape but small in the legs.

VC :Naor Ziv - Soft all around. Needs a lot more mass.

VC : Comparisons going on now.
Sami could be the dark horse here. He has better overall shape than English and Raymond.

Nathan Detracy looks great as well

D'après Campell et Harris , Raymond impressionnant et bonne condition et English pas top et il se pointe juste pour le fric , enfin si je comprends bien l'anglais

1st Call Out :

Sami, Kevin and Jose

VC : Sami has it all but a little long waisted. Theres more going on with his physique than the others.

RH : Sami Kevin Jose - top 3 right here!

3 diff looks - gotta say Sami is better than I thought he was - Jose is the only one with clearly striated glutes - Sami is tallest - Jose thickest

VC : Kevin is off and Sami is got it all going on today. Jose looks better than last week.

2nd Call Out

Raul Carrasco
Guy
Marco Rivera

VC : In this call out both Marco and Guy are looking good but Marco is outsizing Guy at this stage but from the back Guy has more upper back separation.

RH : I give this one to Marco - better overall balance than Guy - this Raul would look better if he posed better - really awkward - his shape is weird too - when Guy's upper body matches his legs, look out!

Third Call Out

Raul Carraso
Nathan Detracy
Mboya Edwards

RH : Mboya is sharpest = Nathan looks a bit blurry next to him - not sure why they left Raul up there? Mboya wins this one

VC : athan - Nice calves, looks young, has great potential. Needs to have better condioning.Out of these three guys Mboya has better condition.

4th Call Out

Milton holloway
Naor
Luis Santa
Santiago
Panax

Final Call Out : ( pour le top3 j'ai bien l’impression)

RH : Jose, Sami, Kevin again - I would hate to be a judge. Clearly it's going to be tough scoring this. Sami prob has best shape - Jose and Kevin bigger

VC : Again, Sami has better shape and better overall conditioning from head to toe.

Apparament Sami serait le mieux proportionné et la meilleur forme des 3 mais à voir les photos.

et maintenant place à l'Open ! YES

VC : Sean Allan has a massive frame which makes it difficult to fill.Looks very lean on the legs.He's lacking fullness.

VC : Tomas Bures - Really well conditioned but straight up and down with no real taper.Good calves and hamstrings.

RH : BSA Big Sean Allen - tall, still needs legs - noticeable pec tear - huge shoulders, chest arms

RH : Tomas Bures from Czech Repub- awesome color, in shape - nice balance and shape - could use more overall mass

Sami Al-Haddad

RH : Jonathan Delarosa in pro debut - THICK - glutes and hams striated -

VC : Jon Delarosa - Making his Pro Debut - Packing a lot of muscle. Great hanging hams from the side.Massive calves. Could be a bit wider from the back.

VC : Vaughn Ettienne - This guy is WIDE! Has a great structure but his conditioning is not deep enough. Could be a lot tighter.

RH : Vaughn Etienne - NOT a 202 anymore! incredibly wide delts - think he used Dream Tan and it washed out his details because he does not look crisp

Sami



elle claque celle la !